Nanny Cams: Breaches of Privacy?

January 28th, 2021

Undoubtedly the surveillance industry has grown over the past 20 years.  Electronic manufacturers now make spy technology that is more durable, effective, and affordable than anything that had come onto the scene since the nineties. 

As this technology becomes more affordable and prevalent, one must ask what are the limits of the law with this technology?  When can you use it and when can you not?

According to national nanny cam laws, it is generally considered legal to videotape nannies without their permission.  However, if you videotape using audio, then the act is dangerously close to being considered as eavesdropping or wiretapping.  The laws that explain the nature of eavesdropping or wiretapping vary from state to state.

One should never expect privacy in the home of another, and many parents in Chico CA and advocates of the nanny cam argue that installing hidden cameras and spy technologies in their home is not an invasion of privacy.

US courts, in fact, found that evidence obtained via a nanny cam/hidden camera was legitimate in the case of the State v. Diaz, 706a.2d 264 (1998), generally considered the most prominent case on this topic.  The prosecution was for assault and child endangerment.  The court ended up concluding that it was ones constitutional right to film in their own home, and the nanny was not  protected under any sort of privacy laws in this case.   However, a recording with sound (and without the permission of the nanny) is illegal in many states, including: California, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Oregon, Pennsylvania and Washington state.  Then again sound on a video can be muted, and it is likely that a video with muted sound could be admitted as evidence. 

And yet nanny cams might not be as private as you think.  In fact, many who install this novel security in their homes in Chico CA, end up opening a window on their activities to the outside world without even knowing it.   Since most nanny cams are wireless cameras (transmitting the signal from the camera to a base, usually a television or computer), signals can be easily intercepted.  A camera with a signal-scrambling function may be able to block such interception, though otherwise your images can be intercepted from up to a quarter-mile away.  But if a court finds that the video was used for any purpose other than protection of a child or guarding against theft for instance, for the purpose of voyeurism or commercial purposes then the video can likely be used against you, the owner of the nanny cam.

Wiretapping laws only protect against audio wiretapping and therefore almost anyone can spy on your nanny cam without legal punishment. It has been demonstrated that a simple drive around the suburbs with a security expert could easily pick up the signals of nanny cams and view the images being filmed inside of private homes.  Basically anyone with a little computer knowledge can hack into your live-feeds and see whats going on in your home.

Some who have been cautious of this fact, have decided to create no camera zones, or carefully place cameras in areas where privacy wasn't a concern.  In general, though, the prevalence of nanny cams has soared and their benefits may outweigh their disadvantages.

What Our Customers Say

"I had the Alibi system installed several years ago. It has functioned flawlessly. The image quality is exellent both night and day and in all weather conditions. I particularly like the replay (which can be set at various speeds) and zoom functions of the system. Tech support from Crimefreeliving has been excellent. I have received quick responses to questions, and timely home visits — as when I changed IP carriers and my Alibi system needed to be reset. I have recommended Crimefreeliving to several friends."


"As a small business owner here in Chico we definitely saw the need for video surveillance. After expressing our needs and concerns Tim did an excellent job getting us set up with the set up with the appropriate equipment. He really took the time to address our concerns in a very friendly, professional and knowledgeable manner. I highly recommend Tim for all of your business and residential video surveillance needs."

Ron H., Owner/Auto Doctor

"I have to say I love having my security cameras at my home. Tim Truby did a wonderful job of installing the five cameras. He is very neat and cleaned everything up after the installation. He explained to me how to operate the monitor, my phone and IPad. However, I have had to call Tim because I'm not tech savvy and forget what he has told me. He usually just helps me over the phone and then all is well. I'm 80 years old and enjoy the comfort of knowing I have these security cameras."


"Tim Truby designed and installed a 32 camera system for us here at the Butte County Mosquito and Vector Control District. We had received several other quotes from security system vendors, but Tim’s quote was the least expensive. Tim also installed the system quickly and has always been available when we needed him. We are very happy with our security camera system and we can highly recommend Tim Truby for all of your surveillance system needs."

D. Weseman, Butte County Mosquito and Vector Control District

Crime Free Living updated our old video system with a new 16 Channel HD Alibi Video Security System. The old system had been added onto by different installers which resulted in a cabling mess. There were cables that worked and cables that went nowhere. It was a mess. Tim sorted it all out and installed cameras that are very clear. He also installed a monitor for our cashiers to watch hidden areas, a monitor to watch the entry door, and a monitor that allows employees to watch the outside parking and gas pump area. All work was done on time and very professional! Will always recommend Tim and Crime Free Living.

S. AM PM Chico Arco Station

"I had Tim install an Alibi Video Security System at my residence and a couple business locations. The remote view option is invaluable to absentee owners or anyone who travels a lot. The clarity and quality of the cameras have allowed for viewing employee theft. The evidence provided from the HD video cameras was fantastic! Tim was professional and provided extra value from his law enforcement background."

J. Folsom Arco Station

"Tim, I want to thank you again for doing such a fantastic job on installing a wireless IP security camera system at our dream home. The extra time that you took to hide wires, and install a clean, professional system is much appreciated. I still can’t believe the clarity, quality, and ease of use of this new system. I wished that I would have met you before our original inferior system was installed by another company. Now, whether I am at home, or monitoring the system from around the world, I know that my home and family are safe and sound."

John M.

"In April of 2017, my husband and I made a phone call to Crime Free Living that turned out to be a smart and wise decision. Amazingly, in just a few hours, Tim installed four Dome Security Cameras, weatherproof enclosures, and hooked up into our home a 23" Full HD Widescreen Security Monitor. Even more than his professional expertise was the time spent with us in making sure that this system was working correctly and properly installed on our phones so that anywhere in our travels we can monitor our new home in Magalia."

Tieka and Don S.

"I have been using Crime Free Living for the last couple years ar work and at home and I really recommend this product. Tim is a very good service provider. If he can't figure it out, he's got good tech support with the system that he offers."

Gary D.

"I have known Tim for over 10 years. To date, Time with Crime Free Living has installed two separate surveillance systems for my company. With each system, Tim has listened to my needs and custom dsigned surveillance systems for my specific needs and within my budget. The equipment used is always state of the art, the workmanship is top notch, and Tim is the example of trustworthy. I would recommend him for any job."

Steve D., Down Range Indoor Training Center

images Certifications & Training

With 16 years of experience in law enforcement, Tim Truby, CEO, is fully certified in video surveillance and training.

  • Certified Advanced Crime Prevention Specialist
  • Academy Instructor Certification
  • California POST Certification in Specialized Surveillance Equipment
  • California POST Certification in Basic Crime Prevention
    • Advanced Crime Prevention through Environmental Design
    • Certified Alibi Security Dealer
    • Enhanced Risk and Threat Assessment (FEMA)
    • Incident Command System (100 & 200)
    • Certified Cognitech Video Forensic Investigator
    • Neighborhood Watch Toolkit Trainer
    • Computer Crimes/Investigations
    • Domestic Crisis for Crisis Negotiators